Hail, your roof and your home insurance
Hail is the biggest reason home insurance costs so much along the Front Range. The age of your roof, what it is made of and how your policy pays for it decide what a storm costs you. This guide explains the terms in plain English.
- Wind and hail deductibles turned into dollars
- Roof payment terms compared before you buy
- Credits for impact-resistant roofing
Quick answer
How does hail affect home insurance in Colorado Springs?
Colorado Division of Insurance data shows hail accounts for about half of homeowners premiums along the Front Range and Eastern Plains. Insurers look closely at roof age and material, often use a separate wind and hail deductible set as a percentage of your coverage, and may pay for an older roof at its depreciated value. Comparing those terms matters as much as comparing the price.
Terms that decide what a hail claim pays
- Wind and hail deductible
- A separate deductible for wind and hail, often 1% or 2% of the coverage on your house. At 2% on a home insured for $500,000, you pay the first $10,000.
- Replacement cost roof
- Pays to replace damaged roofing with new materials, minus your deductible.
- Actual cash value roof
- Takes depreciation out first, so an older roof pays much less.
- Roof payment schedule
- Pays a set share of the roof cost based on its age. The older the roof, the smaller the share.
- Cosmetic damage exclusion
- Excludes dents and marks that do not let water in. It is common on metal roofs.
Ways to lower what hail costs you
You cannot stop the storms, but you can change how much they cost you.
Choose the deductible on purpose. A higher wind and hail deductible lowers the premium. Pick an amount you could actually pay the week after a storm.
Ask before you re-roof. Many carriers give a credit for impact-resistant shingles that carry a Class 4 rating under the UL 2218 test. Ask which products qualify and what paperwork they need before the roofer orders materials.
Keep records. A dated photo set of your roof, siding and windows, plus the year and material of the roof, makes underwriting and claims faster.
Compare the fine print. Two quotes with the same price can pay very different amounts on the same roof. Tony lines up the deductible and the roof terms side by side.
After a hail storm
Stay safe and take photos
Photograph damage to the roof, siding, windows and vehicles from the ground, with the date.
Prevent more damage
Cover broken windows or a leaking roof, and keep the receipts. Reasonable repairs to stop further damage are usually covered.
Start the claim
Call Tony or your insurance company. Ask for your deductible amount before you commit to anything.
Let the adjuster inspect first
Meet the adjuster before you sign with a roofer, so the scope of the claim is agreed.
Know your rights with roofers
Colorado law protects homeowners when they hire a roofer for an insurance claim. The rules are below.
Colorado roofing law, in plain English
Storm chasers follow hail across the Front Range. Colorado law sets rules for any residential roofing job over $1,000:
- The roofer must give you a written, signed contract with the scope, cost and approximate dates of the work.
- The roofer cannot pay, waive or rebate your insurance deductible, and cannot advertise or promise to.
- You can cancel within 72 hours of signing. If insurance is paying, you can also cancel within 72 hours of your insurance company telling you the claim was denied in whole or in part.
- The roofer must hold your payments in trust until materials are delivered or most of the work is done.
An offer to “cover your deductible” is a warning sign, not a deal.
Questions and answers
Have a different question? Call (719) 960-4898.
Does home insurance cover hail damage?
Yes. Standard home policies cover hail. What differs from policy to policy is the deductible and how the roof is paid for.
Will a hail claim raise my premium?
Weather claims are treated differently from claims you cause, but several claims in a few years can still affect your price and your options. For small damage close to your deductible, talk to Tony before you file.
When is hail season in Colorado Springs?
Most hail along the Front Range falls from May through August, with storms most often in the afternoon and early evening.
Can my roofer pay my deductible?
No. Colorado law does not allow a roofer to pay, waive or rebate your deductible.
Is hail damage to my car covered?
Yes, if your auto policy includes comprehensive coverage. See car insurance.
Is a new roof worth it for insurance?
A newer roof can widen your choice of carriers, move you to replacement cost terms and, for impact-resistant products, earn a credit. Ask Tony to price your policy both ways before you decide.
Sources
- Colorado Politics, February 2026: Colorado Division of Insurance data on hail and wildfire shares of homeowners premiums
- KUNC, February 2026: Colorado home insurance premiums from 2014 to 2024
- Colorado Roofing Association: Residential Roofing Bill of Rights (SB12-038)
Page last reviewed by Tony Holliday.
Find out what your roof terms really are
Send your current policy and Tony will explain your deductible and roof coverage in dollars.
