The Colorado FAIR Plan, explained
The Colorado FAIR Plan is the state’s insurer of last resort for homes that standard insurance companies will not cover. It is a real option, but it covers much less than a normal home policy. Here is what it does, what it leaves out and how Tony can help you apply.
- Standard carriers checked first
- FAIR Plan application submitted for you
- Gap coverage added so you are not left exposed
Quick answer
What is the Colorado FAIR Plan?
The Colorado FAIR Plan is an insurance option created by state law in 2023 for homes and businesses that cannot get coverage from standard insurers, most often because of wildfire risk. Residential policies became available on April 10, 2025. A FAIR Plan policy covers fire and lightning, with optional wind, hail and vandalism coverage, up to $750,000 for the home and its contents combined. You apply through a licensed insurance agent.
What a FAIR Plan policy includes
- Always covered
- Fire and lightning damage to the home and its contents.
- Optional
- Windstorm, hail and vandalism, added as extended coverage.
- Not covered
- Theft, flood, earthquake, personal liability and extra living costs while you are out of the home.
- Coverage limit
- Up to $750,000 in total for the home and its contents.
- How claims are paid
- At actual cash value, which means the value of the home just before the loss, with depreciation taken out.
- Who can apply
- Owners who cannot find coverage in the standard market. United Policyholders notes that applicants usually need three declinations from standard insurers.
- How to apply
- Through a licensed insurance agent or broker. Tony can submit the application.
Why most FAIR Plan homes need a second policy
A FAIR Plan policy on its own leaves big gaps. It does not cover a break-in, a burst pipe, a guest who is hurt on your property, or a hotel while your home is rebuilt. Because claims are paid at actual cash value, an older home can also receive far less than the cost to rebuild it.
A difference in conditions policy, often called a DIC or wrap-around policy, is built to sit beside the FAIR Plan and fill those gaps. It can add liability, theft, water damage and living expenses. Consumer advocates at United Policyholders strongly recommend one whenever the FAIR Plan is your only choice. Tony prices the two together, so you see the full cost of the coverage you actually need.
How Tony helps with the FAIR Plan
Check standard carriers first
A full standard policy is almost always better coverage. Tony makes sure no standard company will write the home before going further.
Document the declinations
If standard companies say no, he keeps the records the FAIR Plan asks for.
Submit the FAIR Plan application
Tony completes and submits the application and explains the coverage options.
Add gap coverage
He quotes a difference in conditions policy for liability, theft, water damage and living expenses.
Re-shop every year
Markets change and mitigation work adds up. Each renewal, Tony checks whether a standard carrier will take the home back.
Questions and answers
Have a different question? Call (719) 960-4898.
Is the FAIR Plan run by the state?
It was created by state law and is overseen by the Colorado Division of Insurance. It is operated by an association of the insurance companies that sell property insurance in Colorado.
Does the FAIR Plan cover hail?
Only if you add the optional extended coverage, which includes windstorm, hail and vandalism. Ask for it. Hail is the most common home insurance claim on the Front Range.
Will my mortgage lender accept a FAIR Plan policy?
Many lenders accept it when the limits meet their requirements. Ask your lender before you buy, and tell Tony what the lender requires.
Is the FAIR Plan more expensive than standard insurance?
It covers less, so compare the FAIR Plan plus a gap policy against any standard offer you can still get. Tony lines up both so you can see the difference.
Can I move back to a standard policy later?
Yes. The FAIR Plan is meant to be temporary for many homeowners. Tony re-checks the standard market each year.
Are businesses eligible?
Yes. Commercial FAIR Plan policies became available on June 17, 2025.
Turned down by standard insurers?
Tony checks every remaining option and can submit a FAIR Plan application with gap coverage.
