Home insurance for new home buyers
Your lender needs proof of insurance before closing. In this market the best time to shop is right after your offer is accepted, because roof age, wildfire score and past claims on the house can change the price, or whether a company will insure it at all.
- Quotes before your insurance deadline
- Roof, wildfire and claim history checked early
- Proof of insurance sent to your lender
Quick answer
When should I get home insurance when buying a house in Colorado?
Start as soon as your offer is accepted. Colorado’s standard purchase contract includes a property insurance termination deadline, which gives you a window to back out if insurance turns out to be unavailable or too expensive. Shopping early leaves time to deal with a roof, wildfire or claim history problem before that deadline passes.
An insurance timeline for buyers
Before you make an offer
Ask about the age of the roof, past insurance claims on the house and, for wooded lots, wildfire exposure.
When your offer is accepted
Send Tony the address. He checks carriers right away, so problems surface early.
After the inspection
Share the roof and inspection findings. A problem found now can become a repair request or a price credit.
Before the insurance deadline
Choose your policy. Know the date of your property insurance termination deadline.
Before closing
Tony sends proof of insurance to your lender. The first year’s premium is usually paid at closing or through escrow.
What changes a quote on a home you are buying
- Roof age and material
- Older roofs raise the price and may be paid at depreciated value after a claim.
- Claim history on the house
- Past claims stay with the property. A CLUE report from the seller lists the claims of the last seven years.
- Wildfire score
- Wooded lots and homes near open space can limit which carriers will write a policy.
- Flood zone
- A lender requires flood insurance for homes in high-risk zones. See flood insurance.
- Rebuild cost
- Coverage on the house should match today’s cost to rebuild, not the purchase price.
- Features of the home
- Wood stoves, pools, trampolines and some dog breeds can affect coverage.
Buying in the Pikes Peak region
Two homes at the same price can cost very different amounts to insure. A house in Black Forest or on the west side faces wildfire scoring. A house on the east side faces more hail. A newer roof in either place helps.
If you are moving here on military orders, read the military and PCS guide too. It covers auto and renters coverage for the weeks around the move.
For real estate agents and lenders
Tony works with real estate and mortgage professionals across the Pikes Peak region to get buyers insured before closing. Send the property address, the buyer’s contact details and the closing date, and he will quote early, flag roof, wildfire or claim history problems before the insurance deadline, and send proof of insurance to the lender.
Questions and answers
Have a different question? Call (719) 960-4898.
Does my lender choose my insurance company?
No. You choose. The lender sets minimum requirements, such as the coverage amount and the deductible.
What is a binder?
A binder is temporary proof that coverage will start on a set date. Lenders often accept it until the policy documents are issued.
What if no company will insure the house?
Use the time before your insurance deadline. Tony checks standard and specialty carriers and, if needed, the Colorado FAIR Plan. If coverage is not workable, talk to your agent about your contract options before the deadline passes.
Should I bundle home and auto?
Usually. Most carriers give a discount on both. Tony also checks the price of keeping them separate.
When does coverage start?
On your closing date, so the home is covered the moment it becomes yours.
Sources
- Colorado Division of Real Estate: approved real estate contracts and forms
- KUNC, February 2026: Colorado home insurance premiums from 2014 to 2024
Page last reviewed by Tony Holliday.
Under contract?
Send the address and your closing date. Tony will quote before your insurance deadline.
