Skip to content

Home insurance for homes in wildfire areas

If your home is near forest on the west side of Colorado Springs, in Black Forest, around Monument or up Ute Pass, you may have seen a non-renewal notice, a big price increase or a short list of companies willing to quote. This guide explains why, what Colorado law now gives you, and how to widen your options.

  • Carriers that still write in your area, checked for you
  • Mitigation work documented so it counts
  • FAIR Plan and gap coverage when nothing else is available

Quick answer

How do I get home insurance in a high wildfire risk area of Colorado?

Start shopping at least 60 days before your policy renews, and work with an independent agent who can check many carriers at once. Document any wildfire mitigation you have done, because Colorado insurers that use wildfire scores must now consider it. If no standard company will insure the home, the Colorado FAIR Plan provides basic fire coverage, and a separate gap policy can cover most of what it leaves out.

Why wildfire changed home insurance around Colorado Springs

The Pikes Peak region has lived through two of the most destructive fires in Colorado history. The 2012 Waldo Canyon Fire destroyed 346 homes, most of them in the Mountain Shadows neighborhood. A year later, the Black Forest Fire burned 14,280 acres and destroyed 511 homes.

Insurance companies now rate every address with wildfire models. Colorado Division of Insurance data shows wildfire risk makes up anywhere from 0.9% to 24.6% of homeowners premiums, depending on the county. In neighborhoods with high scores, some companies have raised prices, tightened their rules or stopped writing new policies. In 2024, The Gazette reported insurers pulling back across Colorado Springs, including in Black Forest.

A high score does not mean a home cannot be insured. It means fewer companies will offer a policy, and it pays to have someone who knows which ones still do.

Your rights under Colorado’s wildfire insurance law

A 2025 state law, HB25-1182, gives homeowners new rights. The disclosure rules began on October 1, 2026. They apply to standard (admitted) insurance companies and to the Colorado FAIR Plan.

Your wildfire score
Insurers that use a wildfire model must tell you your property’s score or risk class, where it falls in the full range, and which features of the property or area raised it.
A plain explanation
The notice must explain in plain language how the score was set. It cannot be buried in fine print.
When you receive it
New applicants get it within 15 days of a completed application. Current policyholders get it with the renewal offer, or with a non-renewal notice.
Credit for mitigation
Insurers that use wildfire scores must account for qualified mitigation work in their pricing or offer a discount, and must publish their discount information online.
An appeal
You can appeal a score, risk class or discount you believe is wrong. The insurer must acknowledge the appeal within 10 calendar days and decide within 30 calendar days.
What it does not cover
Surplus lines insurers, which are not licensed as standard insurers in Colorado, are not covered by these rules.

Mitigation that insurers notice

The Colorado State Forest Service divides the land around a home into three zones. Work closest to the house matters most, because embers start most home fires during a wildfire.

Zone 1: the first 5 feet

Keep this ring free of anything that burns. Swap bark mulch for gravel, move firewood and patio furniture away, and clear leaves and needles from gutters, decks and roof valleys.

Zone 2: 5 to 30 feet

Thin trees and shrubs so their crowns do not touch, prune lower branches, and mow grass short.

Zone 3: 30 to 100 feet

Thin dense stands of trees and remove dead ones, so a fire slows down before it reaches the home.

Keep photos and receipts of every project, and ask each insurer which mitigation standards it recognizes. Colorado regulators recommend asking that question directly.

What to do if you receive a non-renewal notice

  1. Note the end date

    Find the date your coverage ends and the reason given. Do not wait for the last week to start shopping.

  2. Call Tony right away

    He checks the standard carriers that still write in your area first, which is usually where the best coverage is.

  3. Gather your records

    Roof age and material, mitigation photos and receipts, and any past claims. Strong records widen your options.

  4. Compare every route

    If standard carriers decline, Tony checks specialty companies, then the Colorado FAIR Plan with a gap policy.

  5. Bind before the old policy ends

    Start the new policy before the old one stops, so there is no gap your lender would flag.

Questions and answers

Have a different question? Call (719) 960-4898.

Does home insurance cover wildfire?

Yes. Standard home policies cover fire, including wildfire and smoke damage. The challenge in some neighborhoods is finding a company willing to write the policy, not the coverage itself.

Can my insurance company drop me because of wildfire risk?

Insurers can choose not to renew a policy, as long as they follow Colorado’s notice rules. Since October 2026, the notice must include your wildfire score and how it was set, and you can appeal the score if it is wrong.

Will mitigation lower my premium?

It can. Insurers that use wildfire scores must account for qualified mitigation or offer a discount. Each company sets its own standards, so ask before you spend money, and keep records of the work.

What is a surplus lines insurer?

A company allowed to insure risks that standard companies turn down. Surplus lines policies can fill a gap, but they are not covered by Colorado’s insurance guaranty fund or by the new wildfire disclosure rules, so Tony explains the trade-offs first.

What is the Colorado FAIR Plan?

The state’s insurer of last resort for homes standard companies will not cover. It covers fire and lightning, with optional wind, hail and vandalism coverage. Read the FAIR Plan guide.

My neighborhood is a Firewise community. Does that help?

It can. The new law counts community-level mitigation as well as work on your own property, depending on the standards each insurer recognizes.

Turned down or non-renewed?

Send the address and the date your policy ends. Tony will check every route to coverage.

Call Tony Get a free quote