Home insurance in Colorado Springs
Hail, wildfire and rising rebuild costs have changed home insurance along the Front Range. Tony compares dozens of carriers so your home gets the coverage it needs at a price that makes sense.
- Wind and hail deductibles explained in dollars before you buy
- Rebuild cost checked against local construction prices
- Options for homes other companies have declined
Quick answer
How do I get good home insurance in Colorado Springs?
Compare several insurance companies, not one. Each carrier weighs hail, wildfire and roof age differently, so prices for the same Colorado Springs home can vary widely. An independent agent such as Tony Holliday runs that comparison for you and explains the two terms that matter most here: the wind and hail deductible, and how the roof is paid for after a claim.
What a standard home policy covers
Most owner-occupied homes are insured on a form called an HO-3. It has six parts.
- The house
- Pays to repair or rebuild your home after covered damage such as fire, wind or hail. The limit should match today’s cost to rebuild, not the price you paid.
- Other structures
- Fences, sheds and detached garages, usually set at 10% of the limit on the house.
- Personal property
- Furniture, clothes, electronics and other belongings, at home or away.
- Loss of use
- Hotel, rent and extra living costs while your home is repaired after a covered loss.
- Personal liability
- Legal costs and damages if someone is hurt on your property or you damage someone else’s property.
- Medical payments
- Small medical bills for a guest who is hurt at your home, whoever was at fault.
What a standard policy leaves out
Every home policy has gaps. These are the ones that matter most in El Paso County.
- Flood. Rising water from creeks, storm runoff or a burn scar is not covered. It takes a separate flood policy.
- Earthquake and earth movement. Excluded unless you add earthquake coverage.
- Sewer and drain backup. Usually an inexpensive add-on, and worth having in a home with a finished basement.
- Wear and tear. Insurance pays for sudden damage, not for a roof that has simply aged out.
- High-value items. Jewelry, firearms and collectibles have low built-in limits. Scheduling them closes the gap.
What drives the price of home insurance here
Colorado is among the five most expensive states for home insurance, and average premiums more than doubled between 2014 and 2024. Four things explain most of what you pay in Colorado Springs.
Hail and your roof
State data shows hail accounts for about half of homeowners premiums along the Front Range and Eastern Plains. The age and material of your roof are the first things an insurance company looks at. Read the hail and roof guide.
Wildfire
Homes near the western foothills, in Black Forest and up Ute Pass get a wildfire score. A high score narrows the list of companies willing to offer a policy. Read the wildfire-area guide.
Rebuild cost
Your coverage limit should reflect what local contractors charge to rebuild today. Limits set years ago are often too low.
Claim history and deductible
Past claims on you or on the property raise the price. A higher deductible lowers it, as long as you could comfortably pay that amount after a storm.
Replacement cost, actual cash value and your roof
These two terms decide how much a claim pays.
Replacement cost pays what it costs to repair or replace the damage with new materials, minus your deductible. Actual cash value subtracts depreciation first, so an older roof or older belongings pay out much less.
Many companies now pay replacement cost on a newer roof and actual cash value on an older one, or use a payment schedule that shrinks as the roof ages. Two policies with the same price can pay very different amounts after the same hail storm. Tony shows you which way each quote works before you choose.
How a home quote works
Tell Tony what you need
Send the form or call (719) 960-4898 with the address. The year the home was built, the age of the roof and your current policy help if you have them.
Tony compares carriers
He checks price and coverage across the companies that fit your situation, then walks you through the options side by side.
You choose
Pick the policy you want. Tony sets it up, sends proof of insurance where it is needed, and stays your contact after that.
Questions and answers
Have a different question? Call (719) 960-4898.
How much is home insurance in Colorado Springs?
It depends on the home. The roof, the cost to rebuild, the wildfire score for the address, your deductible and your claim history all move the price. Colorado is among the most expensive states for home insurance, mostly because of hail and wildfire, so comparing carriers matters more here than in most places. Tony can give you real numbers for your address.
Does home insurance cover hail damage?
Yes. Standard home policies cover hail. Check two things on any quote: the wind and hail deductible, which is often a percentage of your coverage on the house instead of a flat dollar amount, and whether the roof is paid at replacement cost or at its depreciated value.
Does home insurance cover wildfire?
Yes. Fire is a covered cause of loss on standard home policies, and that includes wildfire and smoke damage. The harder part in some neighborhoods is finding a company that will write the policy. See the wildfire-area guide.
Is flood damage covered?
No. Home policies exclude flood. A separate flood policy covers it, and most have a waiting period before coverage starts, so do not wait for a storm in the forecast.
What is a wind and hail deductible?
It is a separate deductible that applies only to wind and hail claims. It is often 1% or 2% of the coverage on your house. On a home insured for $500,000, a 2% deductible means you pay the first $10,000 of a hail claim.
My insurance company did not renew my policy. What now?
Call Tony as soon as the notice arrives, so there is time to shop before the policy ends. He checks other standard carriers first, then specialty companies, and the Colorado FAIR Plan if nothing else is available.
How much coverage do I need on the house?
Enough to rebuild it at today’s construction prices. That figure is usually different from the market value and from the mortgage balance. Insurance companies run a rebuild-cost estimate, and Tony checks that it matches your home’s size, finishes and features.
Can I bundle home and auto insurance?
Yes, and it usually lowers both. Tony also prices them separately, because two companies sometimes beat one bundle.
Get a free home insurance quote
Send the address and a few details. Tony compares carriers and comes back with real numbers.
- No cost and no obligation
- Several carriers compared in one request
- A licensed local agent, not a call center
Prefer to talk? Call (719) 960-4898, Monday to Friday, 8:30 am to 5:30 pm.
Sources
- KUNC, February 2026: Colorado home insurance premiums from 2014 to 2024
- Colorado Politics, February 2026: Colorado Division of Insurance data on hail and wildfire shares of homeowners premiums
- The Gazette via United Policyholders, July 2024: Colorado Springs home insurance market
Page last reviewed by Tony Holliday.
