Home and auto insurance in Colorado Springs, compared for you
Tony Holliday is an independent agent in downtown Colorado Springs. Tell him what you need once. He compares coverage and price across dozens of A-rated carriers, then explains your options in plain English.
- Works for you, not for one insurance company
- Licensed since 1986, Colorado license #578934
- Downtown office at 102 S Tejon St, open Monday to Friday
Serving the Pikes Peak region
Dozens of carriers
One request is checked against many insurance companies.
40 years licensed
Tony has held an insurance license since 1986.
A local office
Downtown Colorado Springs, not a call center.
Goosehead Insurance agent
Colorado license #578934.
Quick answer
What does an independent insurance agent do?
An independent agent is not tied to one insurance company. Tony Holliday compares home, auto and life policies from dozens of carriers, shows you how the price and coverage differ, and sets up the one you choose. The quote is free and there is no obligation to buy.
Coverage Tony can quote
Choose what you need. Quoting home and auto together is usually the quickest way to lower both.
- Home insuranceHail, wildfire and rebuild-cost coverage for Front Range homes.
- Car insuranceLiability, collision and comprehensive, with hail in mind.
- RentersYour belongings and liability, on or off post.
- CondoWalls-in coverage that fits your HOA master policy.
- Landlord and rentalRental houses, duplexes and short-term rentals.
- Personal umbrellaExtra liability over your home and auto policies.
- Life insuranceTerm and permanent coverage for the people who rely on you.
- MotorcycleBikes, gear and passengers, year-round or seasonal.
- RV and motorhomeMotorhomes and travel trailers, parked or on the road.
- Boat and watercraftBoats and personal watercraft for Colorado reservoirs.
- FloodCreek and burn-scar flooding that home policies leave out.
- Every type of coverageSee all home, vehicle, life and liability coverage.
Why insurance costs more here, and what Tony does about it
Colorado Springs sits between two expensive risks. Hail storms roll off the Front Range every summer, and the west and north sides of El Paso County border forest that has burned before. Insurance companies have responded with higher prices, stricter roof rules and, in some neighborhoods, fewer companies willing to write a policy at all.
An agent who represents one company can only offer that company’s answer. Tony can check dozens. When a renewal jumps or a company pulls back from your area, he re-shops your coverage, looks for credits you have earned, and tells you plainly what each choice costs and what it leaves out.
If you are dealing with one of these right now, start with the guide that fits: hail and your roof, homes in wildfire areas, or the Colorado FAIR Plan for homes that standard companies have declined.
How a quote works
Most quotes take one short conversation and one follow-up.
Tell Tony what you need
Send the form or call (719) 960-4898. An address or a vehicle and what you carry today is enough to start.
Tony compares carriers
He checks price and coverage across the companies that fit your situation, then walks you through the options side by side.
You choose
Pick the policy you want. Tony sets it up, sends proof of insurance to your lender or the DMV, and stays your contact after that.
Help with hard situations
Some insurance problems are specific to this part of Colorado. These guides explain each one plainly.
- Wildfire-area homesWhat to do when your home is near forest and quotes are scarce.
- Colorado FAIR PlanHow Colorado’s insurer of last resort works and what it leaves out.
- Hail and your roofRoof age, hail deductibles and how claims are paid.
- Military and PCS movesMoving to Fort Carson, Peterson, Schriever or the Academy.
- New home buyersGetting coverage in place before your closing date.
What clients say
Tony’s reviews are on Google, where anyone can read them. If he has helped you, a short review helps your neighbors find him.
Serving Colorado Springs and the Pikes Peak region
Tony works with clients across El Paso and Teller counties, in person downtown or by phone and email. Choose your town for local details.
Plain answers from the blog
Sourced, plain-English articles on the questions Colorado Springs homeowners and drivers ask most.
- November 11, 2026How Much Is Home Insurance in Colorado Springs?A 2026 report puts Colorado’s average home insurance premium at $4,310 a year. See what sets the price in Colorado Springs and nine ways to lower yours.
- November 11, 2026How Much Is Car Insurance in Colorado Springs?Colorado drivers pay $1,865 a year on average, or $2,712 for full coverage. See what drives car insurance prices in Colorado Springs and how to pay less.
- November 11, 2026Home Insurance Non-Renewal in Colorado: What to Do NextGot a home insurance non-renewal notice in Colorado? Learn the 60-day notice rule, your rights and the steps that get new coverage before yours ends.
Common questions
Have a different question? Call (719) 960-4898.
Is Tony Holliday Insurance part of Goosehead Insurance?
Yes. Tony Holliday is a licensed Goosehead Insurance agent. Goosehead is the national independent agency he works through, which gives him access to its carriers. Tony Holliday Insurance is his local office in downtown Colorado Springs.
How much does a quote cost?
Nothing. Quotes are free and there is no obligation to buy.
Which insurance companies does Tony work with?
As an independent agent, Tony can quote dozens of national and regional carriers. Which ones fit depends on your home, vehicles, location and history, so he checks several for every quote.
What do I need for a quote?
For a home: the address, the year it was built, the age of the roof if you know it, and your current policy if you have one. For a vehicle: the year, make and model, the drivers in your household, and your current coverage limits.
Do I have to come to the office?
No. Most clients handle everything by phone and email, and documents are signed online. You are also welcome at the office at 102 S Tejon St, Suite 1128, Colorado Springs, CO 80903, Monday to Friday, 8:30 am to 5:30 pm.
Can Tony insure a home in a wildfire area?
Often, yes. It takes more work than it used to. Tony checks which carriers still write in your area, looks at credits for mitigation work, and can place a Colorado FAIR Plan policy when no standard company will. See the wildfire-area guide.
Will Tony still help after I buy the policy?
Yes. He reviews your coverage at renewal, re-shops it if the price jumps, and can guide you when you have a claim.
Get a free quote
Tell Tony what you need. He compares carriers and comes back with real numbers.
- No cost and no obligation
- Several carriers compared in one request
- A licensed local agent, not a call center
Prefer to talk? Call (719) 960-4898, Monday to Friday, 8:30 am to 5:30 pm.
