Quick answer
A captive agent sells insurance for one company. An independent agent can quote policies from many companies and move you between them. Carriers in Colorado Springs keep changing their rules for hail and wildfire risk. An independent agent can re-shop your coverage without sending you back to square one. A captive agent can still be a good fit if that one company suits your home, your cars and your budget.
Most people pick an insurance agent the way they pick a dentist. A friend makes a referral, or an office is close to home. The type of agent matters just as much, because it decides which companies you get to see.
This guide explains the three main ways to buy insurance, how each one works and how to choose the right fit for your household.
The three ways to buy home and auto insurance
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners, the national group of state insurance regulators, describes agents this way.
Captive agents sell insurance for only one company. They are sometimes called exclusive or direct agents. They know that company’s products well, and they can only offer what it sells.
Independent agents may sell policies from many different companies. They can compare several carriers for the same home or car and recommend the one that fits best.
Buying direct means dealing with the company itself by phone or online, with no local agent. You do the comparing yourself.
The NAIC also notes a fourth role. An insurance broker searches the market on your behalf and generally charges a fee for the service. Agents of both kinds receive a commission from the insurance company instead.
How captive and independent agents compare
| Question | Captive agent | Independent agent |
|---|---|---|
| How many companies? | One | Many |
| Who pays the agent? | The company, by commission | The companies, by commission |
| What happens if your price jumps? | Options within that company | A quote from other carriers |
| What if the company stops writing your area? | Start over with a new agent | Move you to another carrier |
| Who handles a claim? | The company, with agent help | The company, with agent help |
The rows that matter most in Colorado right now are the last three. When one company raises rates or pulls back, a captive agent can only work within that company. An independent agent can bring you offers from others.
Why the choice matters more in Colorado right now
Colorado home insurance premiums more than doubled between 2014 and 2024, according to KUNC. Hail drives about half of homeowners premiums along the Front Range, and wildfire models now shape where carriers will write new policies.
In 2024, The Gazette reported insurers raising prices, tightening their rules and pulling back across Colorado Springs, including in Black Forest. When that happens, the company that insured your home for years may no longer be the best fit, or even an option.
With a captive agent, a non-renewal means finding a new agent and starting over. With an independent agent, it usually means a phone call and a set of new quotes. That flexibility matters most for homes in wildfire-area and hail-heavy neighborhoods, where carrier rules change most often.
A simple example
Picture a family in Rockrimmon with a home, two cars and a teen driver. Their home insurer raises the premium sharply at renewal and adds a 2% hail deductible.
With a captive agent, the family can adjust coverage within that one company. They might raise the deductible further or drop an option to bring the price down. If the family wants a different company, they need a different agent.
With an independent agent, the same call starts a new comparison. The agent quotes the home and cars with several carriers, holds the deductible and roof terms steady, and shows which option keeps the coverage while lowering the cost. The family may still stay put. The difference is that they decide with the full picture in front of them.
How independent agents choose which carriers to quote
Independent agents can only quote companies that have appointed them. That list differs from agency to agency, so two independent agents may not offer the same choices.
Each carrier also has its own appetite. One may like newer homes with impact-resistant roofs. Another may accept older homes but prefer certain ZIP codes. A good independent agent knows those preferences and sends your application to the carriers most likely to say yes at a fair price. Ask which companies the agent plans to quote for you, and why.
When a captive agent may be the better fit
Independent is not always better. A captive agent can be the right choice when:
- That company already offers you the best price and coverage for your situation.
- You value a long relationship with one company and its programs.
- The company has a discount or program that fits your household well.
- Your home and vehicles are easy to insure, and you rarely need to shop.
The honest test is simple. Get at least one independent quote and one captive quote on the same coverage. Then compare the price, the deductibles, the roof terms and the service you can expect.
What a good agent does after you buy
The sale is the start of the relationship, not the end. Whichever type of agent you choose, expect help with these moments:
- Renewals. A review when the premium changes, and a fresh comparison when it jumps.
- Life changes. A new driver, a new roof, a remodel, a home business or a move all change what you need.
- New risks. An RV, a boat, a rental property or an umbrella policy should fit with the coverage you already have.
- Claims. Help reporting a claim, understanding the adjuster’s estimate and following up when it stalls.
A local agent also knows the region. Someone who works in Colorado Springs every day knows which neighborhoods carriers rate as high wildfire risk, which roofs earn credits and how hail season plays out. That knowledge shows up in better questions and fewer surprises.
What to ask any agent before you buy
Whichever type you choose, these questions show how an agent works:
- Are you licensed in Colorado? You can confirm a license through the Colorado Division of Insurance or the NAIC’s consumer search tools.
- How many companies can you quote for me? The answer tells you how wide the comparison will be.
- How will you compare the quotes? Look for side-by-side terms, not just a single price.
- What are my wind and hail deductible and roof terms in dollars? A good agent can answer before you buy.
- Who answers my calls after I buy? Ask whether you will reach the agent, a service team or a call center.
- Will you review my coverage at renewal? Some agents re-shop automatically when a price jumps.
- How do you get paid? Most agents are paid by commission. A broker may charge a fee.
The NAIC adds two more tips. You should never feel pressured to choose an agent, a company or a quote. And if an offer seems too good to be true, it probably is.
How Tony Holliday works
Tony Holliday is a licensed Goosehead Insurance agent with an office in downtown Colorado Springs. Goosehead is an independent agency, which gives Tony access to dozens of national and regional carriers. He has held a Colorado insurance license since 1986, Colorado license #578934.
For each quote, Tony checks several carriers for your home, vehicles and any extras like an umbrella policy. He lays out the deductibles and roof terms side by side, then helps you choose. At renewal, he re-shops your coverage if the price jumps.
If you want to see how an independent comparison looks for your household, request a free home and auto quote or call (719) 960-4898. You can also read more about Tony Holliday and his background. For another way to lower your bill, see when bundling home and auto saves money.
Questions about independent and captive insurance agents
Does an independent agent cost more?
Usually not. Independent agents are paid by commission from the insurance company, like captive agents. You pay the premium for the policy you choose. A broker who charges a separate fee should tell you so before you agree to anything.
Can an independent agent help with claims?
Yes. The insurance company handles and pays the claim, but your agent can explain your coverage, help you report the claim and follow up if it stalls. Ask about claim support before you buy.
What is the difference between an insurance agent and a broker?
An agent sells policies on behalf of one or more insurance companies and is paid by commission. A broker represents you while searching the market and generally charges a fee. In everyday use, people often use the two words for the same job, so ask how the person is paid.
Can I switch to an independent agent and keep my insurance company?
Sometimes. If the independent agent is appointed with your current company, the company may let you move the policy to that agent. Ask before you cancel anything, so your coverage never lapses.
How do I check an insurance agent’s license in Colorado?
Use the license lookup tools from the Colorado Division of Insurance or the NAIC. Confirm the person and the agency hold active Colorado licenses, and check for complaints before you buy.
Sources
- NAIC: How to choose an insurance agent
- KUNC, February 2026: Colorado home insurance premiums from 2014 to 2024
- Colorado Politics, February 2026: Colorado Division of Insurance data on hail and wildfire shares of homeowners premiums
- The Gazette via United Policyholders, July 2024: Colorado Springs home insurance market
- Goosehead Insurance: Tony Holliday, Colorado Springs
